Lindsay

Share

  • Follow
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest

Lindsay
Review

  • Editorial
  • Interviews
  • Reviews
  • Photo Essays
  • Recipes
  • Magazine
  • About

Search via Topic

  • Architecture
  • Art
  • Business
  • Craft
  • Culture
  • Design
  • Environment
  • Fashion
  • Film
  • Food
  • History
  • Literature
  • Music
  • Photography
  • Reviews
    • Film
  • Sport

Search via Location

  • A
  • Alice Springs
  • Antwerp
  • Argentina
  • Australia
  • B
  • Barcelona
  • Beirut
  • Belgium
  • Belgrade
  • Berlin
  • Borneo
  • Brazil
  • C
  • California
  • Canada
  • Chile
  • China
  • Colombia
  • Cornwall
  • Côte d’Ivoire
  • Cuba
  • Cuernacava
  • D
  • Denmark
  • E
  • England
  • Everywhere
  • F
  • Finland
  • France
  • G
  • Germany
  • H
  • Havana
  • Helsinki
  • Hiroshima
  • Hội An
  • Hong Kong
  • Hungary
  • I
  • Iceland
  • India
  • Indonesia
  • Israel
  • Istanbul
  • Italy
  • J
  • Jabalpur
  • Japan
  • Jersey
  • K
  • Kenya
  • Kiribati
  • Krakow
  • Kuala Lumpur
  • Kyoto
  • L
  • Lebanon
  • Lisbon
  • London
  • Los Angeles
  • Luxembourg
  • Lyon
  • M
  • Malaysia
  • Marrakech
  • Melbourne
  • Mexico
  • Mexico City
  • Mongolia
  • Morocco
  • Mount Fuji
  • Myanmar
  • N
  • New Caledonia
  • New Mexico
  • New York
  • New Zealand
  • Nigeria
  • Norway
  • O
  • Oslo
  • P
  • Papua New Guinea
  • Paris
  • Penang
  • Peru
  • Poland
  • Portland
  • Porto
  • Portugal
  • Province of Girona
  • R
  • Rio de Janeiro
  • Rome
  • Russia
  • S
  • Santiago de Compostela
  • Scotland
  • Serbia
  • Singapore
  • South Africa
  • Spain
  • Sri Lanka
  • St. Petersburg
  • Sumba
  • T
  • Taipei
  • Taiwan
  • Tangier
  • Tanzania
  • Tel Aviv
  • Texas
  • Thailand
  • Tokyo
  • Turkey
  • U
  • United States
  • USA
  • V
  • Varanasi
  • Venezuela
  • Venice
  • Vietnam
  • W
  • Wales
  • Y
  • Yangon

‘Good Bye, Lenin!’ Bids Farewell to a Divided Germany

REVIEW / Germany

28 August, 2017

Words: Max Hayward

 

Film, History, Berlin, Germany, 

Good Bye, Lenin!—a tragicomic sensation upon its release in Germany in 2003—remains underseen in much of the English-speaking world. This is surprising when considering both its tonal and aesthetic similarities to the worldwide hit Amélie (2001), and the general lovability of the film’s breakout star, Daniel Brühl.

“Seemingly within moments, the Berlin Wall is being torn down—the GDR has failed and Christiane has no idea.”

The story starts in the autumn years of the German Democratic Republic (GDR), where Alexander (Brühl), his mother Christiane (Katrin Saß), sister Ariane (Maria Simon) and infant niece Paula, share an apartment in East Berlin. As Alexander grows up, Christiane has become more supportive of the oppressive Socialist party, whereas he’s becoming more rebellious. When she witnesses her son being arrested at an anti-government demonstration, she literally has a heart attack. Alexander is soon released from detention to see his mother, and finds her lying in a coma. Seemingly within moments, the Berlin Wall is being torn down—the GDR has failed and Christiane has no idea.

The rapid succession of events in this first act could have easily been mishandled, but director Wolfgang Becker (Me and Kaminski) and editor Peter R. Adam, subtly interweave archival footage from the era into the film, which creates a fabric of scratchy authenticity.

“So with the help of his initially hesitant sister, they transform the family’s rapidly Westernising apartment back to nostalgia-drenched East Berlin style, so Christiane thinks nothing has changed.”

While Christiane is comatose, Alexander sits next to her in a sombre waiting game, until he starts to find solace in his crush on nurse Lara (Chulpan Khamatova). Together, they smoke a joint at a party in a half-destroyed apartment building, share knowing smiles and glances, and eventually kiss in Christiane’s hospital room. Of course, after eight months, that’s the moment Christiane snaps out of her coma.

The doctor gives Alexander permission to take care of his mother at home, with the warning: “You must protect her from any kind of excitement or upset.” So with the help of his initially hesitant sister, they transform the family’s rapidly Westernising apartment back to nostalgia-drenched East Berlin style, so Christiane thinks nothing has changed. They find old food jars (pickles, jams) to replace their Western products, and Alexander even enlists his filmmaker friend Denis (Florian Lukas) to create staged news reports adding another layer of ostalgie through archival footage—keeping in style with the scrapbook aesthetic of the film.

The plan works seamlessly, for a while, until Christiane notices fragments of Western culture on TV, and on billboards outside. Inquisitive, she sneaks out of the apartment, and finds herself in a very different Berlin. As the piano score (by Amélie composer Yann Tiersen) swells, and her eyes glass over in the sunlight, you feel the melancholy pouring out from this former hardliner Socialist, wandering into a place that’s vividly colourful, but covered in ads for IKEA and Coca-Cola, after years of tonal sameness. It’s a moment that’s emotionally reminiscent of The Truman Show, when Truman discovers what he’d suspected: the world he lived (and believed) in is phoney.

“Everything, from Christiane’s favourite East German pickles to Alexander’s t-shirts to the statues of political figures throughout Berlin, must one day change.”

What is most rewarding (and relatable) about Good Bye, Lenin! is the film’s intimate scale and humble third act. Rather than ending with an expository monologue or punchline, Christiane and Alexander quietly accept that the world is changing, and ultimately, they can’t always protect each other from exterior political or personal forces. Everything, from Christiane’s favourite East German pickles to Alexander’s t-shirts to the statues of political figures throughout Berlin, must one day change.

In present-day Berlin, architectural remnants of the GDR years still feature prominently throughout the cityscape—particularly around Alexanderplatz, where the Fernsehturm (TV Tower) continues to be an imposing reminder of Germany’s divided past. A social nostalgia for East German life also lingers with some older Berliners, as told in Anna Funder’s compassionate book Stasiland (2002). But the transformation of physical barriers (like the Wall itself) into public art spaces, and the repurposing of old industrial buildings into hedonistic nightclubs, are just two examples of the city’s much-discussed continual reinvention. Good Bye, Lenin! captures this energy through, not only the superficial changes to the city (Western billboards, brighter colours), but also the emotional relationship between past and present, embodied by Christiane and Alexander.

Good bye, Lenin! by Wolfgang Becker (2003), 121 minutes, Germany

Notes

Max Hayward is a Melbourne-based writer who is passionate about film musicals and mimosas.

I: @macs_heywood

Editorial
The Magic of Mexico City’s Underground Metro
Editorial
Beci Orpin Discovers a Community of Independent Retailers in Portland

View More: Film Review, Review, Film, History, Germany, Berlin, 

Recommended Reading

Editorial / Germany

Freikörperkultur Lake Swimming

Olivia Dennis shares the infectious freedom that comes from being an unnoticed naked body in one of Berlin’s approximate 80 lakes and recommends her favourite spots to enjoy this local pastime.

Film Review / Russia

From Poetry to the Big Screen; ‘A Room and a Half’ Captures Russia’s Artistic History

In Andrei Khrzhanovsky’s film ‘A Room and a Half’ (2009), we are taken ‘back’ to Joseph Brodsky’s Leningrad in the only way the poet, exiled at the age of thirty-two, could revisit it: through memory and imagination.

Film Review / New Zealand

Ghostly Intimacy at the Edge of the World: Jane Campion’s ‘The Piano’

A man’s world is seen through a woman’s lens in New Zealand’s cinematic triumph. Max Hayward reviews this intimate story between man and woman, woman and piano, as it unravels in an unknowable, rain-drenched landscape.

Film Review / Peru

Che Guevara’s Political Awakening in ‘The Motorcycle Diaries’

Max Hayward reviews this full-hearted biopic following a charismatic Che Guevara and his friend Alberto Granado as they navigate the windswept landscape and harsh social climate of South America.

Film Review / Italy

‘Call Me By Your Name’: a Tale of Inimitable Love Leaves its Mark

The latest film by Italian director Luca Guadagnino transports us to a romantic northern Italy, drenched in summer light and a tender love. Olivia Dennis reviews one of the most intimate love stories in recent cinematic history.

Film Review / USA

The Story of America Told Through the Words of James Baldwin

Max Hayward draws our attention to past and present race relations in America through the powerful and poetic words of civil rights activist and writer James Baldwin in the essayistic documentary ‘I Am Not Your Negro’.

Film Review / India

“The organic way in which director Shubhashish Bhutiani approaches aging and death is decidedly anti-Best Exotic Marigold Hotel; the story isn’t about fulfilling dreams, it’s about the acceptance of death.”

Max Hayward on Shubhashish Bhutiani’s Hotel Salvation

Film Review / France

‘Breathless’ (À Bout de Souffle): Jean-Luc Godard’s New Wave Ode to Youth

Considered one of the films that kick-started the French New Wave (Nouvelle Vague), Jean-Luc Godard’s ‘Breathless’ is a rule-breaking tribute to youthfulness, recklessness and gangster movies. Max Hayward escorts us through this black and white 60s Parisian maze.

Film Review / Hong Kong

Wong Kar-wai’s Cinematic Muse, Hong Kong, Shines in ‘In the Mood for Love’

Max Hayward walks us through Wong Kar-wai's dizzying portrait of a man and a woman living in a ramshackle Hong Kong neighbourhood in—what has been granted time and time again—one of the best films ever made.

  • About
  • Shop
  • The Club
  • Subscribe
  • Events
  • Stockists
  • Contact
  • Contributors
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest

Lindsay is a biannual print and online magazine published by Oak Park. Website designed by Oak Park and built by Fine Thought.

Subscribe to our newsletter
Close

Lindsay Readers Club

Join our community of curious, worldly readers. Sign up to receive invitations to special events, exclusive offers, and occasional stories direct to your inbox.

* indicates required

Welcome to the club!

Keep an eye out for our mail to make sure we’re not lost in spam or your promotions folder.