Lindsay

Share

  • Follow
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest

Lindsay
Review

  • Editorial
  • Interviews
  • Reviews
  • Photo Essays
  • Recipes
  • Magazine
  • About

Search via Topic

  • Architecture
  • Art
  • Business
  • Craft
  • Culture
  • Design
  • Environment
  • Fashion
  • Film
  • Food
  • History
  • Literature
  • Music
  • Photography
  • Reviews
    • Film
  • Sport

Search via Location

  • A
  • Alice Springs
  • Antwerp
  • Argentina
  • Australia
  • B
  • Barcelona
  • Beirut
  • Belgium
  • Belgrade
  • Berlin
  • Borneo
  • Brazil
  • C
  • California
  • Canada
  • Chile
  • China
  • Colombia
  • Cornwall
  • Côte d’Ivoire
  • Cuba
  • Cuernacava
  • D
  • Denmark
  • E
  • England
  • Everywhere
  • F
  • Finland
  • France
  • G
  • Germany
  • H
  • Havana
  • Helsinki
  • Hiroshima
  • Hội An
  • Hong Kong
  • Hungary
  • I
  • Iceland
  • India
  • Indonesia
  • Israel
  • Istanbul
  • Italy
  • J
  • Jabalpur
  • Japan
  • Jersey
  • K
  • Kenya
  • Kiribati
  • Krakow
  • Kuala Lumpur
  • Kyoto
  • L
  • Lebanon
  • Lisbon
  • London
  • Los Angeles
  • Luxembourg
  • Lyon
  • M
  • Malaysia
  • Marrakech
  • Melbourne
  • Mexico
  • Mexico City
  • Mongolia
  • Morocco
  • Mount Fuji
  • Myanmar
  • N
  • New Caledonia
  • New Mexico
  • New York
  • New Zealand
  • Nigeria
  • Norway
  • O
  • Oslo
  • P
  • Papua New Guinea
  • Paris
  • Penang
  • Peru
  • Poland
  • Portland
  • Porto
  • Portugal
  • Province of Girona
  • R
  • Rio de Janeiro
  • Rome
  • Russia
  • S
  • Santiago de Compostela
  • Scotland
  • Serbia
  • Singapore
  • South Africa
  • Spain
  • Sri Lanka
  • St. Petersburg
  • Sumba
  • T
  • Taipei
  • Taiwan
  • Tangier
  • Tanzania
  • Tel Aviv
  • Texas
  • Thailand
  • Tokyo
  • Turkey
  • U
  • United States
  • USA
  • V
  • Varanasi
  • Venezuela
  • Venice
  • Vietnam
  • W
  • Wales
  • Y
  • Yangon

‘The Hour of the Star’: A Philosophical and Piercing Introduction to Brazilian Literature

REVIEW / Brazil

2 July, 2018

Words: Olivia Dennis

 

Literature, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, 

My introduction to the work of Clarice Lispector was subtle, almost unnoticeable. A pilates teacher of mine—lovingly known for her inability to stay silent through class—had peppered our sessions with quotes of her’s, mostly from Lispector’s seminal work Agua Viva. The quotes always stuck and I noted them down after each class, not fully aware of who they came from or why they lingered. They were just phrases I liked, companions that I clung to. I had not read Lispector before; in fact until a few years ago, I was largely blind to the diversity and power of Brazilian literature.

Pilates is not necessarily a common teaching ground for Lispector’s words, nor literature in general, but my teacher loved her. She loved the prose, the ambiguity, the ability for “breath to hold itself so gently in her sentences.” After inquiring about the name of the author of such potent words after class one day, I was firmly directed into the arms of Lispector, where I have comfortably remained ever since.

The Hour of the Star is Lispector’s last published work. In plot, the story is quite simple. Written shortly before she died, it tells the tale of a poor typist in Rio named Macebéa. The book is short, and predominantly filled with a melting pot of musings on life, truth, existence and spirituality—themes that pervade much of Lispector’s collection. It’s narrated from the mouth of a wealthy and elderly Brazilian man, formally and exclusively known as Rodrigo S.M. The lifestyle and upbringing of Rodrigo S.M. and Macebéa are in direct contrast, yet both characters seem lost, almost vague.

Macebéa hails from Alagoas—a town in northeast Brazil—and later settles in Rio de Janeiro. The Hour of the Star echoes the journey of the author, whose family first arrived in Alagoas after emigrating from Poland. Macebéa is poor, uneducated and dirty. She is perceived to be so acutely dim that she does not realise her dullness… Yet she is also impossibly bright. She harnesses the reader’s sympathy and attention fully. Our narrator Rodrigo S.M. is in ways deeply profound and philosophical, in others comical, self-serving and dry. He has this ability to make a crude comment on Macebéa’s outfit or lifestyle only to follow with a poignant statement about God, life or otherwise. He is angst-ridden, crippled with insecurity in his fiscally comfortable world.

“Trapped in a somewhat sexist and class-driven world of urban Brazil, she seems too foreign for this big city; crumpled by a city with a personality so much larger than her own.”

Rodrigo S.M. follows Macebéa’s day-to-day life around Rio. He comments on her poor status in finance, intelligence and culture. She is a girl who is both too simple and too complicated. Trapped in a somewhat sexist and class-driven world of urban Brazil, she seems too foreign for this big city; crumpled by a city with a personality so much larger than her own. It’s also the same feeling of displacement that seems to shadow Lispector herself: forever an emigrant, floating through place. Despite this, Rio de Janeiro has an unwavering appeal through these pages. It is eccentric, passionate, hot and clammy. The sweat of the city seems to seep through each pore of Lispector’s text.

As the novel frequently moves between dark and light, there is a sense of instability that Lispector counteracts with her firm hold on the reader, refusing to allow us to avert our gaze. The novel is both mysterious and revealing; sweeping generalisations make way for astute statements and small observations. Only the work of a great writer and translator can find this balance as well as Lispector does.

Translation is an art as much as writing itself. The Hour of the Star has been translated numerous times, and I imagine, more in the future. The beauty in translation is that each read can reveal something different. While the key message remains the same in most sentences, by nature of language, with every translation each word can subtly change meaning, adjusting our interpretation even just slightly. Considering that the book was written in Portuguese, with a vocabulary that far expands that of English, there’s certainly room for interpretation. In parts of the novel, the tone drifts slightly, making you question if you’ve missed something: sarcasm, perhaps, that might be familiar to those of the novel’s mother tongue but not easily understood by someone reading in English.

Though The Hour of the Star digs deeply into the dark abyss of the human condition, it is also an impassioned, open-armed welcome to all those who feel they are struggling to be something, to do something. It is a philosophical novel, tenderly piercing our notions of normality, of society, of life, and of death. French feminist Helene Cixous once said of Lispector: “there, further ahead, where the philosopher loses his breath, she continues, still further, beyond all knowledge.” In her isolated plain beyond all knowledge, Lispector delicately and vulnerably exposes our beautiful, tragic world for exactly that: its beauty and its tragedy.

The Hour of the Star by Clarice Lispector, translated by Giovanni Pontiero (1992) and Benjamin Moser (2011), 1977, 87 pp.

Notes

Olivia Dennis is a screen and fiction writer. Born and raised in Surrey, England, she currently resides in Melbourne, Australia. Her work intimately explores character, with a particular focus on the interactions between humans and the spaces surrounding them.

T: @livvydennis / I: @livdennis_

Photo Essay
At Home… In a Trove of Art and History in Cuernavaca
Photo Essay
Building Culture… in Havana

View More: Book Review, Review, Literature, Brazil, Rio de Janeiro, 

Recommended Reading

Book Review / Vietnam

In the Heat and the Haze: Marguerite Duras’s Love Affair

The real life affair of writer Marguerite Duras in 1930s French Indochina (former Vietnam) challenged gender, social and racial stereotypes. Nearly a century later, Rachel Wilson revisits this transgressive yet ever-intoxicating relationship in Duras’s award-winning novel “The Lover.”

Book Review / England

Zadie Smith Takes Us to an ‘Ungentrifiable’ North West London

In this review of Zadie Smith’s narrative and experimental novel ‘NW,’ Olivia Dennis introduces us to four thirty-somethings born of their location—a diverse and divided district of London.

Book Review / Spain

“I gazed at the deep blue Mediterranean below the mountain and felt at peace.”

Sofia Papastergiadis, Hot Milk

Book Review / Italy

‘Famiglia’: a Tale Told Through Food

Food, over family, brings the characters together in Natalia Ginzburg’s 1977 dissection of the Roman middle-class.

Book Review / Japan

“Ozeki’s portrait of a modern country tightly threaded with the past leaves us not with concrete explanations but a feeling for the country’s delicate ambiguity.”

Katherine Brabon on Ruth Ozeki’s A Tale for the Time Being

Book Review / France

“We are made of all the places we’ve loved, or of all the places where we’ve changed.”

Lauren Elkin, Flâneuse

Music Review / Brazil

“I can’t always work out whether I am in a dark jazz club in Manhattan’s Lower East Side or dancing in Copacabana.”

Olivia Dennis on Eliane Elias’s Dance of Time

Film Review / USA

The Story of America Told Through the Words of James Baldwin

Max Hayward draws our attention to past and present race relations in America through the powerful and poetic words of civil rights activist and writer James Baldwin in the essayistic documentary ‘I Am Not Your Negro’.

Interview / United States

The Short Stories of Another New York: An Interview with Jenny Zhang

Her short stories captured the attention of Lena Dunham, and then readers worldwide. Jenny Zhang speaks to Shu-Ling Chua about writing ‘Sour Heart’, her relationship with New York and Shanghai, and how she’s needed to carve her own path.

  • About
  • Shop
  • The Club
  • Subscribe
  • Events
  • Stockists
  • Contact
  • Contributors
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest

Lindsay is a biannual print and online magazine published by Oak Park. Website designed by Oak Park and built by Fine Thought.

Subscribe to our newsletter
Close

Lindsay Readers Club

Join our community of curious, worldly readers. Sign up to receive invitations to special events, exclusive offers, and occasional stories direct to your inbox.

* indicates required

Welcome to the club!

Keep an eye out for our mail to make sure we’re not lost in spam or your promotions folder.